The nurse is like a mother to Juliet while the Friar is like an uncle to Romeo. Nurse always cares for Juliet and tells her the right things and supports her. She lets Juliet follow her own heart. Through line 190-193 Act 2 Scene 4 it says " I anger her sometimes, and tell her that Paris is the proper man, but I'll warrant you, when I say so, she looks as pale as any clout in the versal world." What I think in this line is that the nurse is telling Romeo how Juliet gets when she tells her Paris is better man. But she is doing what Juliet wants her to do and she supports her. She proves she is a fun nurse and she kids with her a lot. For example, in Act 2 scene 5, line 38- 42 Nurse jokes about Romeo "You know not how to choose a man. Romeo? No, not he. Though his face be better than any man's, yet his legs excels all men's, and for a hand and a foot and a body, though they be not to be talked on, yet they are past compare. He is not the flower of courtesy, but, I'll warrant him as gentle as a lamb"
With Friar and Romeo it looks like the Friar is like a close uncle to him that cares for Romeo even he is not a regular boring priest. It seems the Friar is more close to Romeo than Romeo with his father. An example would be line 48 Act 2 Scene 3 " Friar: That's my good son! But where hast thou been then?" He cared for Romeo and gets worried when he gets involved with wrong people like Rosaline. Also he agrees to get Romeo married to Juliet fort the sake of Romeo and peace. Line 94 Act 2 Scene 4 "Friar: ...but come, young waverer, come go with me. In one respect I'll thy assistant be, For this alliance may so happy prove to turn your households' rancor to pure love."
Some examples of unhealthy relationships in "Romeo and Juliet" could be Lady Capulet and Juliet and maybe Mercutio and Romeo.
Lady Capulet and Juliet don't get along well. Their mother and daughter relationships doesn't seem to exist and maybe in some way it could have been the nurse's fault. But that is just my opinion. Sometimes I feel like Lady Capulet is scared to talk to Juliet because she thinks Juliet hates her, which maybe true, but she doesn't make any effort to even try. Once she made an attempt to talk to her alone, but changed her mind and got Nurse instead.
Some examples of unhealthy relationships in "Romeo and Juliet" could be Lady Capulet and Juliet and maybe Mercutio and Romeo.
Lady Capulet and Juliet don't get along well. Their mother and daughter relationships doesn't seem to exist and maybe in some way it could have been the nurse's fault. But that is just my opinion. Sometimes I feel like Lady Capulet is scared to talk to Juliet because she thinks Juliet hates her, which maybe true, but she doesn't make any effort to even try. Once she made an attempt to talk to her alone, but changed her mind and got Nurse instead.
Lady Capulet:" This is matter. Nurse, give leave awhile, We must talk in secret. Nurse, come back again. I have remembered me, thou's hear our counsel. Thou know eat my daughter's of a pretty age." Act 1 Scene 3 lines 8-11. She brought nurse back so she didn't have to deal with Juliet. Or it also could be a good relationship in a different way. Maybe she wanted Juliet to be stronger than she is and have more freedom. Or maybe not.
With Romeo and Mercutio their relationships with one another could be good or bad. Mercutio is a really good friend to Romeo. Even if he's not a Montague he's with Romeo. Basically, Mercutio is the leader of the Montague boys because the other boys are to scared to battle Tybalt. But, Mercutio and Romeo could have a bad relationship as well. Mercutio didn't support Romeo with their fight with Tybalt. And I think he died because he didn't agree with Romeo's decision. Instead he cursed both families. Mercutio:"I am hurt. A plague on both your houses! I am sped. Is he gone and hath nothing?" Act 3 Scene 1 lines 84-86
Although some relationships have good in them they also have the bad. I think we have to try to at least make it work. Not ignore the bad. Or the good. Life has issues. That is just what life is. And I think a good relationship has no certain start or end.. Even when you see a person for the first time and you instantly want to go out with him/her. And that's what I think is normal. And that is what I think Shakespeare would have thought was normal.
In my opinion, I think he writes his play based on real life situations with a bit of fiction in them. I think he had a tough life and I think he used his play to express his feelings.
In my opinion, I think he writes his play based on real life situations with a bit of fiction in them. I think he had a tough life and I think he used his play to express his feelings.
I liked how you decribed Romeo and Friar's relatioship as an uncle and nephew, I never even thought about that until i read this. :) And that's interesting that you think that Juliet and her mothers relatioship was ruined by the nurse, do you have any quotes that could possibly support that opinion?
ReplyDeleteHello, i am from USA, I want to share this great testimony about how Dr.Agbazara helped me bring back my ex lover, During my search for solution i came in contact with Dr.Agbazara details and through his help my lover came back to me within 48 hours. So with these i am so bold to advise anyone seeking for a way to get there lover back to contact Dr.Agbazara on WhatsApp: { +2348104102662 } or via email at: { agbazara@gmail.com } I am so happy at least myself and my lover are back to each other again and going to spend the New Year celebration together Thank to Dr.Agbazara once again....
DeleteGreat job!! I also agree with Melissa that's really cool how you described Romeo and the Friar's relationship like uncle and nephew. Great job keep it up!!:)
ReplyDeleteThis is a fantastic post. You have totally unique insights and comparisons of relationships that we haven't discussed in class. I agree with Melissa I would like to hear more about how you think the Nurse may have played a part in the disintegration of the real mother and daughter relations? Be careful that while seeing both sides is of value you don't want to make your writing too vague. Acknowledge possible differences but finish with your position. :) Great job.
ReplyDelete